Ending on a Different Note

Nicholas Seekely Response

Shannon McAdoo Critique

Saturday, April 23, 2011

3A: A Song and It's Cover

                                                          "Viva La Vida" by Coldplay


"Viva La Vida" Cover by Joy Electric


Lyrics

Not to much can be said about the lyrics in cover besides the fact that either by accident or on purpose Joy Electric uses the line “Pillars of Sand, Pillars of Sand” when in the Coldplay original it goes “Pillars of Salt and Pillars of Sand”. I don't know why he would change that because he didn't change any other lyrics and I think it was a honest mistake. On another note, the lyrics don't have quite the emotional feel when it's all electric sounding because the song details the events of the second French Revolution and there aren’t even any drums in the background when he is singing about drums. It just doesn’t have the 1800's feel with a modern twist. More like a somebody tried to take classical music and synthesize it. It can be done but not here.

Melody

The melody’s in both of the versions are about the same just with different instrumentation. In the original it comes from bass guitar and somewhat Chris Martin's voice where as in the Joy Electric version it comes a electric beep noise that changes pitch. Once again the original is just a more pleasant sounding melody and it works with Chris' voice better.

Musical Quality

In terms of rhythm the tempo is exactly the same medium to fast tempo throughout both songs. Like noted above the rhythm for Coldplay's version comes from the heavy drums while the cover's comes from a synthetic beat. The groove is hard to place... Coldplay's is a bit more poppy while Joy Electric's might be considered more riddim. The intensity generally is that the original varies more while the cover stays about the same throughout. Pitch stays the same in both pieces as far as I can tell. Timbre is where the songs are vastly different because they have different styles. The classical mixed with pop really works for Coldplay's while the electric just doesn’t fit with the lyric and tone of the piece. Also Coldplay is a professional band so they can afford to have great editors to clear up any problems with the audio which I'm not sure Joy Electric has access to. The speed is the same for both pieces as well so we wont dwell on it. The organization is also somewhat diverse in both songs. The Coldplay one has the changing style at the end with the raising voices and the shouts where as that does not carry over into the cover. It's there but not really emphasized like in the original.

Verdict

I'm a die-hard Coldplay fan so of course I'm going with the original on this one. I'm not one of those people who goes with the original always but in this case the original just works better than the cover. It's more pleasant to listen to and fits the lyric better than the electric version where it diverges from the story of the words. In terms of lyrics, melody and the musical quality all points go to the original. I'm never really hear a Coldplay cover that was that good but Alicia Keys has made a decent attempt with hers. Even Coldplay has acknowledged that and performed with her. I Don't think Joy Electric is going to ever get that far.

No comments:

Post a Comment